Have you ever been on a team where one person consistently pushes back, and the leader has learned to treat that voice as the most valuable in the room? Are you that person?
The dissenter, while sometimes annoying, is a protective hedge for your organization. A voice of reason. The devil’s advocate. Not always right, but worth listening to.
Research on groupthink in organizational settings consistently identifies at least one genuine dissenting voice as the single most effective preventive against the cascade of poor decisions that unchallenged group consensus produces. The dissenter is necessary to defend against groupthink.
The multifamily team member who consistently asks the uncomfortable question, names the risk, and holds the standard is performing the most valuable organizational function.
The leader who has learned to welcome the dissenter rather than manage them, who creates specific conditions in which the dissenting voice is heard before the consensus is formed, is protecting the organization from the most expensive failures. Generally, these are the ones that were preventable if someone had been willing to speak up!
The dissenter pushes back in every meeting. Sometimes it’s exhausting. But the leader who gets the bigger picture invites these insights and opinions. Pushback can and will prevent a decision that would cost the property management firm dearly. Others in those rooms will not always welcome the friction. This says more about them than it does about the dissenter. Protect your dissenter. Not at all costs, and not in all circumstances. Your senior meetings might run smoother, but your firm will suffer.
The multifamily firm that silences its dissenters has removed its canary from the coal mine. The failures that follow were always preventable. — Mike Brewer
Discussion prompt: Who in your organization most consistently voices the perspective that the room does not want to hear? When was the last time that perspective prevented a costly mistake? What structures do you have to ensure that voice is heard before decisions are made rather than after?