The Multifamily Operations Daily Huddle: Have a Theory of Your Market

What do you say when your asset manager asks: “Why does your submarket behave differently from the one across the interstate?”

Some property managers or regional managers can answer that in two minutes. They can name the employers driving demand, why pricing holds or slips, the source of seasonal swings, the mix of competing properties, and their comparative strengths and weaknesses.

Statistician George Box wrote that all models are wrong, but some are useful. You don’t need a perfect model of your submarket. You need a useful set of causal beliefs about what drives demand, what moves pricing, what creates the seasonality you see, and what could change the market’s behavior.

Revenue management software is helpful, but it optimizes inside its model. The human with a theory can tell when the model needs an edit. Side note: there are some 300-plus or minus levers internal to any revenue management software. Review them on a quarterly basis based on your theory of the market.

Building one takes steady attention: the local employment base, population movement, the construction pipeline, infrastructure projects that will reshape the area over the next five years, and conversations with residents, brokers, and economic development members. Important note: for anything about competitors, stick to public sources and your own data.

Imagine the value of this expertise and the basis for your theory. It’s not only impressive to an asset manager or an owner; it’s also hugely valuable for forecasting an asset’s business plan not to mention future disposition/acquisition strategies.

Be diligent, however. As Box’s point cuts both ways. A theory earns trust by surviving new evidence. Write down what would prove yours wrong, check it every quarter, and revise it as soon as the market disagrees.

Build a theory of your market, act on it early, and change it the moment the market proves it wrong. — Mike Brewer

Discussion Prompt: Could you explain in two minutes why your submarket behaves the way it does, and what evidence would tell you your explanation is wrong?

Leave a Reply