“Dear Resident, effective August 1, your monthly rent will be…”
Imagine two nearby properties sending the same increase in the same month, all else equal. One team sends a boilerplate form letter. The other sends a personalized note that uses the resident’s name, says hi to their pet (by name), thanks them for three years in the building, explains what’s driving the change, and offers a phone call. Which team secures the renewal?
Economists Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch, and Richard Thaler studied this reaction in 1986. They asked people whether a hardware store that raised the price of snow shovels the morning after a snowstorm was acting fairly, and 82% said it wasn’t. Their broader finding was that people accept price increases tied to rising costs and resent increases that look like the seller exploiting a moment. The reason behind a price shapes the reaction to it.
That makes your renewal notice a fairness test. Consider the following three points to give it the highest chance of succeeding in its intent:
- Name the person and the relationship. Use their name and the length of their residency, and say thank you like you mean it.
- Explain the driver honestly. If taxes, insurance, or payroll rose, say so plainly. If the increase reflects the market, say that too. Be honest.
- Open a door. Offer a call, a choice of renewal terms, or a time to talk before they decide.
Item of note: Always follow all fair housing laws. And follow any state or municipality notification laws; the letter has to clear those before anything else.
It’s all in the delivery!
Discussion Prompt: If you read your last rent increase notice as the resident who received it, would it explain the increase fairly, and what would you change before the next one goes out?